Backyard Eggs VS Store-Bought

Backyard Eggs vs Store-Bought: The Real Truth



If you’ve ever stood in the grocery store staring at egg prices and thought, “Should I just raise my own chickens?”, you’re not alone.

With rising food costs and a growing interest in homesteading, backyard chickens are more popular than ever.

But are they actually cheaper… or is this more of a lifestyle choice?

Let’s break it all down.

The Cost Comparison: Chickens vs Store Eggs

🛒 Store-Bought Eggs

  • Average price as of February 2026 was approximately $2.58

    • I just checked the prices at my local Walmart for an 18 count carton, it is currently $2.47.
    • The price is always subject to fluctuate. During 2025, prices were ranging from $5-$8, in some states. 

  • No labor, no maintenance

  • Always accessible

🐓 Backyard Chickens (Real Costs)

Startup Costs:



So far, start up has been the most expensive part of it. I had to pay for a permit to legally have them in a residential area, which was $100 for 5 years. However, there is some talk about this changing/improving so we'll see how this goes in the future. 

  • Brooder Equipment: $25 to $100 (AARP, 2023)

    • I used a storage bin from Lowe's to keep them as chicks. I bought a heat lamp and the light housing from rural king, used medicated chick starter feed, and some bedding. 

  • Coop + setup: $400–$1,500+ (AARP, 2023)

    • I challenged myself to build the coop primarily out of pallet wood. The wood was free, for the other materials like wood screws, I did have to get a couple of 2 x 4's for the structure build, corrugated metal, and 1/4 inch wire, I say in total I probably spent $150 max. 

  • Chickens: $3–$50 each (Alliant Credit Union, 2022)

    • I spent $5 per chick, I have 4 so $20
    • If you get already producing, egg laying hens, that'll cost between $20 - $50. (Alliant Credit Union, 2022) 

  • Feeders, bedding, supplies: additional

    • I spent about $100 total on this part, max. 

Ongoing Costs:

  • Feed: Est. $20-$50 a month (Alliant Credit Union, 2022)
    • It's taken me about 2 months to get through a 40 lb. bag. Depending on what feed I get can be between $15 and $23 a bag. I let my chickens free range so they graze which probably cuts back on my feed costs. 
  • Bedding: My bedding cost about $6 a bag from rural king. I clear the coop out every 2 weeks on average. It takes me a half bag to refill the coop. 
  • Occasional veterinary care: Estimated $25-$100 per year (AARP, 2023)

Estimated yearly cost: $300 - $800+ (AARP, 2023)

  • Depends on the amount of chickens you have and other variables
  • With our household only having 4 hens, and letting them graze throughout the day, our estimated cost is more likely around $200 a year. 

Reality Check

According to multiple agricultural extensions and financial analyses:

  • Backyard eggs can cost $6–$10 per dozen to produce depending on setup

  • Store eggs average $2.58 per dozen (as of February 2026, subject to change)

Bottom line:
Chickens are usually NOT cheaper — especially in the first 1–2 years

Are Backyard Eggs More Nutritious?

A well-known study by Mother Earth News (2007) compared backyard eggs to store-bought eggs and found:

  • 2–3x more omega-3 fatty acids

  • 25% less saturated fat

  • 40% more vitamin A

  • 2x more vitamin E

Why This Happens

It comes down to diet and lifestyle:

Backyard chickens:

  • Eat bugs, greens, kitchen scraps

  • Get sunlight and exercise

  • Have more varied nutrition

Commercial chickens:

  • Fed standardized grain diets

  • Limited movement

  • Designed for consistent production

⚠️ Important Note: Not ALL backyard eggs are automatically healthier.

Nutrition depends on:

  • What you feed your chickens

  • Whether they free-range

  • Overall chicken health

So yes, they can be more nutritious… but it’s not guaranteed unless you manage their diet well.

Pros of Raising Your Own Chickens

1. Fresh, Better-Tasting Eggs

Richer yolks, better texture, and unbeatable freshness

2. Food Independence

Less reliance on grocery stores and price swings

3. Natural Pest Control

Your chickens help manage bugs in your yard

4. Free Fertilizer

Chicken manure = garden gold

5. Family & Lifestyle Benefits

  • Teaches kids responsibility

  • Connects you to your food

  • They honestly become part of the family


Cons of Raising Chickens

1. Not a Money Saver (Usually)

High startup + ongoing costs

2. Daily Responsibility

  • Feeding

  • Cleaning

  • Egg collecting
    No days off

3. Health & Hygiene

  • Risk of salmonella (CDC guidance)

  • Requires regular coop cleaning

4. Predators

Hawks, raccoons, snakes, even neighborhood dogs

5. Inconsistent Egg Production

  • Takes ~6 months before laying starts

  • Slows down in winter

  • Declines with age

So… Is It Worth It?

YES — If You Value:

  • Higher-quality food

  • Self-sufficiency

  • Homesteading lifestyle

  • Teaching your kids where food comes from

NO — If Your Goal Is:

  • Saving money

  • Convenience

  • Minimal effort

In Conclusion

Raising chickens for eggs isn’t really about saving money.

It’s about building a system.

👉 Garden scraps → chickens
👉 Chickens → eggs + fertilizer
👉 Fertilizer → better garden

That’s where the real value is.

Final Thoughts

For us, raising chickens isn’t just about eggs.

It’s about slowing down, being intentional, and creating something sustainable right in our backyard.

And honestly… watching your kids collect eggs never gets old. ❤️

Works Cited

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Production Red Chickens: When Our Backyard Chickens Finally Started Laying Eggs

Image
We Have Eggs! After months of raising our backyard chickens, we finally had our first exciting surprise in the nesting box, eggs! We got our chickens back in October, and I had been wondering when they would finally start laying. I knew it should happen around this time of year, but there’s something really exciting about opening the nesting box and seeing those first eggs sitting there. One afternoon, I checked the coop and found not just one egg, but several sitting together in the same nesting box. It was one of those small backyard moments that makes raising chickens completely worth it. Why We Chose Production Red Chickens Before we brought our chickens home, I originally planned to get Golden Comets . They’re known for laying a lot of eggs and having a calm temperament, which made them appealing for a backyard flock. However, when we went to our local Rural King, they didn’t have Golden Comets available. One of the employees suggested we look at Production...
Read more

Backyard Chicken Coop Setup

Image
Intro When we decided to start raising backyard chickens, one of the first things we needed was a safe and comfortable chicken coop. In this post I’ll share our backyard chicken coop setup and why we chose to let our chickens free range in our fenced yard. Our Backyard Chicken Coop Setup Raising backyard chickens has been one of the most rewarding parts of starting our little homestead. Not only do we get fresh eggs, but the chickens have also become a fun and entertaining part of our daily routine. One of the most important parts of keeping chickens is having a safe and comfortable coop for them to live in. Today I wanted to share our backyard chicken coop setup and how we care for our flock of Production Red chickens. Our coop isn't fancy, but it works well for our backyard and provides everything our chickens need to stay safe, comfortable, and productive. Watch the Coop Build When we first decided to start raising chickens, we needed a coop that would work well for our backyard...
Read more